Hardwood Flooring Versus Carpet: Which Should You Go With?
There are many options when it comes to flooring, and there are pros and cons to most options. While there are other options (like the many different types of tiling out there), but there’s no question that the two most common choices out there are carpeting and hardwood. Is one clearly superior to the other? What are the pros and cons of either? Does it matter whether building from scratch or renovating? These are all great questions – now read on to find out the answer when comparing carpeting vs. hardwood floors.
There’s a lot to love about what hardwood floors bring to the table. Hardwood floors are a very durable, sustainable option. These can take a beating and take relatively minimal maintenance to keep looking good over time. Most people prefer hardwood to carpeting. It has a classic warm aesthetic that many people love, and while carpeting isn’t going to improve the overall value of a house, in many cases hardwood flooring actually can.
Hardwood flooring is also a great option because it takes a better beating that carpeting from renters, can be refinished to last for decades for homeowners, and they are low allergy in nature, as well.
- Looks much better & generally adds a higher value to the property
- Easy to clean
- Very durable & can last a long time
- Much more expensive than carpeting
- Scratching or scuffing can take place in high traffic areas
- Colder and doesn’t insulate well in cold climates
Carpeting as a Flooring Option
While hardwood flooring brings plenty to the table, carpeting has plenty of positives, as well. If it didn’t, it wouldn’t be one of the top choices. Right off the bat carpet is the much more budget-friendly choice. Often times hardwood will be 3-4 times more expensive. Aside from being cheaper, carpet offers a variety of different styles and looks that many homeowners appreciate. Soft, comfortable, carpeting is not only often a better option for families but it also has the benefits of helping to keep noise down. For colder climates, carpet is also much easier to keep warm.
- Much less expensive than most other options
- Good for families because it’s soft, muffles noise, and helps keep the floor warmer
- Wide variety of styles and looks to choose from
- Will become dirty and/or wear down over time
- Can hold allergens
- Will require replacement much more frequently than hardwood
- Requires Carpet Cleaning
What’s the Verdict?
Situation matters a lot. If budget is the primary issue then chances are that carpeting is going to make more sense than hardwood floors, which are almost certainly going to be much more expensive. Hardwood floors tend to be more durable and long-lasting and can add actual value to a property, but they are expensive. In cold climates that means you’ll need thick socks and slippers in the winter since they will be cold, and when replacement actually needs to take place, it will be more expensive. On the other hand, carpeting will need to be replaced a lot more often and over the long run that will eat into those initial savings. Bad for allergies but good for small kids running around, these both have their strong and weak points depending on what your main focus is.